Spanish Localization versus Spanish Translation
March 05, 2014
"Do you know what the difference between the two processes is? And what about what they have in common?"
Let's start with two short and simple definitions…
Translation is the process of translating/converting words or text from one language into another one.
So we can say that when we talk about localization, we are talking about a translated text that is not only limited to the exact rendition of the terminology in the target language, but also reflects the special cultural aspects of the target market. That is to say, a localized text is an adaptation from both the linguistic and cultural points of view.
What kind of text do you think can be localized then?
Well, we could say that all kinds of text can be localized: literature, manuals, websites, software, brochures, letters, terms and conditions, etc.
Let's think of the localization of a manual or other kind of documentation. Sometimes there are words that need to be not only translated but also localized in order to avoid negative connotations or to simply sound natural in the target language. For example:
- In Spain, the word "carro" is a cart that you push or pull to transport things, whereas in Latin America it's an actual car that you can drive around in. A car in Spain is a "coche", whereas a "coche" in Latin America is a baby stroller.
- The English term "computer" is an "ordenador" in Spain and a "computadora" in LA Spanish speaking countries.
- An "avocado" is an "aguacate" in Spain and a "palta" in most LA Spanish speaking countries.
- A "potato" is a "patata" in Spain and a "papa" in some LA Spanish speaking countries, like Argentina.
- Other words like "pen" show differences between the continents and also within the different countries in Latin America: It's a "bolígrafo" in Spain, a "lápiz pasta" in Chile and a "lapicera" in Argentina.
The process of localization also includes other kinds of techniques and knowledge that are not purely linguistics. The importance of choosing the correct colors in the localization of a website or a multimedia application for example can avoid a negative impact on the target audience. To mention a few instances:
- White means holy in the US and mourning in China.
- Yellow means strength and reliability in Saudi Arabia, but mourning in Mexico.
- Green means luck in the Middle East, but it's a forbidden color in Indonesia.
Localization also plays a key role in software translation. Date and time formats as well as monetary systems change from one country/language to another, so it's crucial that these kinds of elements are properly adapted according to the target language. Another example is language expansion. The localized Spanish version of a dialog box will surely be longer than its original English form, so the screen length will have to be localized for the target language version.
Particularly speaking about Spanish localization, one of the main considerations for Spanish translators is locale. As you can tell from the above examples, Spanish for Spain, Puerto Rico or Argentina is understandable across the Spanish speaking countries, but it's definitely NOT the same Spanish. So suppose a client requests that you translate an English website into Spanish, what locale would you use?
First of all, I suggest you ask your client where the target audience is. If he says Spain, problem resolved! But what happens if he says Spain, Puerto Rico and Argentina? Well… we have two acceptable options here:
- We provide one version in European Spanish (for Spain) and another version in LA Spanish (for Puerto Rico and Argentina).
- We provide a one and only Neutral Spanish version for the three target markets.
The Neutral Spanish option sounds more reasonable and needless to say, less expensive. It's a variation of the Spanish language without the use of colloquialisms or locale-specific terminology. It uses more informal terminology and certain verb tenses and allows the greatest number of Spanish speakers around the globe to understand the translated message.
I must say, it's a mission fulfilled in many situations and with great results. Going back to my previous examples, instead of translating "computer" as "computadora" which would be too Argentinean, or as "ordenador" which would be too Spaniard, a perfect Neutral Spanish version for this technical term would be "equipo" which is commonly accepted and sounds natural in all countries.
Unfortunately, we don't always have a common term that can be used in all Spanish versions and sounds really natural and culturally appropriate to the same degree. So many times we'll have no other alternative than to provide two different Spanish versions, even though much of the content will be very similar.
In conclusion, we can say that today the translation profession is not an isolated one anymore. Most of the translators, whether they are freelancers or not, are inevitably part of a localization services team made up of linguists -translators, editors and proofreaders-, project managers, engineers, desktop publishers and website designers among other professionals, who participate in the localization project from file preparation, translation, localization and testing to final delivery, in order to provide their clients with the translated content they had requested as if it had been originally thought, written and designed in the target language.
Further resources on Spanish translation and localization
You may gain further insights into Spanish language translation and related topics by reviewing blog posts and resources written by GPI:
- Spanish Variations: Spain vs. Latin America
- What is neutral Spanish?
- 9 Effective Tips for Spanish Copywriting
- Insights into Spanish Translations for Latin America
Globalization Partners International has created a more extensive overview of website globalization for U.S. Hispanic consumers on: Website Globalization and E-Business U.S. Hispanic Market.
You may contact GPI at email@example.com or at (US toll-fee) 866-272-5874 with your specific questions about Spanish translation and your project goals. You may also request a complimentary Spanish translation quote for your project as well.
Currently, there are no comments. Be the first to post one!
Marina Cavallera - Assistant Project Manager
Marina is a native Spanish speaker from Rosario, Argentina with over 15 years’ experience as a certified English-Spanish translator and interpreter. She graduated with a dual degree in Technical-Scientific and Literary Translation and Simultaneous and Consecutive Interpreting from the Instituto de Educación Superior Olga Cossettini in Rosario. She has extensive experience with most well known CAT tools including the range of SDL tools such as SDL Trados Studio, MultiTerm, Wordfast, SDL Idiom WorldServer, Translation Workspace, XBench, etc. She has also served as a CAT Tool Instructor conducting an average of 50 courses and workshops for many associations, private institutes and conferences. Over the years she has provided Spanish language translation and interpreting for a multitude of translation agencies, Global Fortune 500 companies, Governments and NGO’s. When not working she enjoys traveling, cooking, reading and movies with her family.